What do you think of my list of heroes and villains of the American Civil War?

I am sorry, but by calling William T. Sherman and Philip H. Sherman "villains" you fail to impress me. Naming these two as "villains" is childish and shows a lack of understanding about the changing nature of war in the 19th century. I think you best remove both Sheridan and especially Sherman - and not because of Sherman's "mental state," either!